Mystery Boxes

Mystery Boxes - Let Us Pick For You

Don't know which puzzle to get? Don't want to choose? Want to be surprised?

Mystery Boxes are exactly what they sound like. You pick the size. We pick the puzzles. You get them in the mail.

You get at least what you paid for - that's the rule. Every puzzle is hand-picked from the Greg Puzzles catalog. No duplicates within a box. No filler. Just puzzles we'd actually recommend.

Two Ways to Mystery

One random puzzle

The simplest version. We send a single hand-picked puzzle - a packing puzzle, an interlocking cube, or whatever else we think you'll enjoy. Low commitment, high surprise.

A curated box of puzzles

Multiple puzzles in one shipment, themed and balanced - a mix of difficulties and styles. The bigger the box, the more puzzles and the deeper the cuts.

Customizable to Your Needs

Every Mystery Box can be tailored to the person receiving it. Tell us about the giftee in the order notes on the cart page - what they love, what they've already solved, the difficulty level that fits them, or anything else that helps us pick - and we'll tailor the experience to them.

The more we know, the better the box.

Why Mystery

  • You stop deciding - no more browsing, comparing, second-guessing
  • You discover something new - the puzzles you'd never have picked yourself are often the ones you end up loving
  • You get at least what you paid for - every box is curated to match or exceed its sticker price in retail value
  • It's the easiest gift you'll ever give - let the surprise do the work

Best for: puzzle lovers who want a discovery experience, gift-givers who don't know exactly what the recipient wants, and anyone who finds choosing a single puzzle harder than solving one.